How to spot an expert
I’ve always felt uncomfortable about the way that some of those people who work with “the blind” actually interact with blind people ourselves.. However, it’s often very subtle and has been hard to put my finger on just what it is that produces the discomfort. Some of it is about the philosophy (at least the historical philosophy) of the charities, some of it is about the way that people in the “care industry” learn to view their service users and some can be directly related to the kind of information that people are given on so called vision awareness training courses.
Some indicators
v They often refer to us as Vis (visually impairds)
v They have an air of slightly over-confident familiarity
v They often speak just a little too loudly – possibly so that others won’t think that they’re blind too and will realise that they’re doing good work, possibly even that they’re wanting people to realise that they know a blind person (“some of my best friends are blind…”)
v They do everything just that bit too properly – they know how to ask you if you want something, how to describe things, how to guide you – but not in a way that shows real respect, care or interest
v They have a way of maintaining their act even when you don’t comply with it.
v They often fall back on poor counselling techniques when they feel a bit uncomfortable
v They have a way of asking in a very knowing and sincere voice “Are you partial or total?”
7 Comments:
Why do you think they feel uncomfortable?
10:02 pm
I think that there is a professional "type" that is created by the still powerful and historic blind charity system. Where the (still) major organisation has and continues to run segregated schools and other institutions, where the often not so covert philosophy is that it is only through sighted people, that blind people can understand the world and function successfully within it. Where the experts on blindness are not blind people ourselves and where we have very clear roles that we mustn't step out of too far. I wonder if the discomfort comes from the gap between this idea and the reality that they really don’t know what it is like not to see and in that unknowing, there is a strange kind of fear of what they can’t know.
I find similar attitudes in other places too of course, but not so pronounced, there’s something about the culture and associated training that these people have gone through.
10:23 pm
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
3:50 pm
I deleted the last comment because of typos.
I'm sure all this is true. I just thought that he felt uncomfortable about difference. The difference between a blind person and himself. Also uncomfortable about feeling glad that he is not blind
3:52 pm
Who's the "he"? I was describing a type, probably met more women than men like this (I guess to the gender split in the care industry
7:19 pm
Ooops! I just imagined him as a man. Maybe its me?
8:53 pm
I work with the blind and we’re not all like this. It’s not helpful to generalise , you’ve clearly got some problems – where would you and others like you be without us? Ask yourself that.
5:09 pm
Post a Comment
<< Home